Shelters

[MikeT]

It would not take a whole lot of work to move a shelter. I would not want to do it, but it would not be that hard. I'm thinking the shelters were moved and the shelter colors were changed to match the 1965 NPS plan (right now I forget what they called it). The colors of the shelters are pretty bad. This picture is a new one to my collection and I need to compare landscapes. I am not sure if this is the current dock location (I think not). It could be at the remnants of a dock next to the current one or, it could be on the other side of Benson Creek; There were two docks listed at Daisy Farm on several park brochures I have.

[Ingo]

A little off-topic, but another thing that's changed: my Uncle flew into McCargoe Cove and Siskiwit Lake in the 50s on a fishing trip. Remnants of a dock on Siskiwit still exist.

[Ingo]

Below is a picture of Daisy Farm from a 1963 postcard.

We rented out those wooden boats at R.H. in 1979. Heavy and slow, but very seaworthy. Same white and orange paint. But folks usually preferred the newer aluminum ones so they didn't get rented much.

[Rafiki]

Thanks for bringing some history to this thread Mike. Very neat collection of artifacts that you have in your possession.

[lellswo]

I think the reason that the shelters are only found at Lake Superior docks has more to do with the wilderness designation of most of the park. Since the Wilderness Act of 1964 states "there shall be no temporary road, no use of motor vehicles, motorized equipment or motorboats, no landing of aircraft, no other form of mechanical transport, and no structure or installation within any such area" (italics added). Authorized exceptions to the prohibition of structures include boardwalks to protect sensitive land, foot bridges over dangerous water crossings, and pit toilets to improve sanitation in high-use areas. You can see on the National Geographic map of the park, all the campgrounds with existing shelters have been carved out of the wilderness designation, which allows the park service to maintain and replace existing structures in those areas. Other structures such as the fire towers and cabins that existed prior to wilderness designation have been grandfathered in.

[Chorizo]

Has anyone seen shelters of the Isle Royale design at any other parks or locations? We have not. Just kind of curious to know how unique they are to Isle Royale.

[Tom]

You can see on the National Geographic map of the park, all the campgrounds with existing shelters have been carved out of the wilderness designation, which allows the park service to maintain and replace existing structures in those areas.

I like the theory, but I'm not sure it's 100% true. There are a lot of places that don't show on the map as non-wilderness that have shelters; Todd Harbor, Chippewa, Duncan Bay + Narrows, many of the small island campsites, etc.
I wouldn't doubt the reason, like pit toilets, is to minimize impact to the land, however.

[Tom]

Has anyone seen shelters of the Isle Royale design at any other parks or locations? We have not. Just kind of curious to know how unique they are to Isle Royale.

I think I once read they are a four-sided variation of the "Adirondack lean-to" found on the Appalachian Trail in the Adirondack mountain area.
I won't be able to confirm until I can get the A.T. bucket list item checked off.

[dcclark]

Has anyone seen shelters of the Isle Royale design at any other parks or locations? We have not. Just kind of curious to know how unique they are to Isle Royale.

Wilderness State Park at the tip of Michigan's Lower Peninsula has a CCC-built shelter very much in the Isle Royale template -- but built with logs, and a massive fieldstone fireplace in front of it (wouldn't that be nice sometimes?!). It's meant to be a warming shelter for skiers.

I had a darn hard time tracking down a photo of it (since "Wilderness State Park" tends to pull up "Porcupine Mountains Wilderness State Park" which is not the same at all). Here's the best one:

[Chorizo]

Has anyone seen shelters of the Isle Royale design at any other parks or locations? We have not. Just kind of curious to know how unique they are to Isle Royale.

I think I once read they are a four-sided variation of the "Adirondack lean-to" found on the Appalachian Trail in the Adirondack mountain area.
I won't be able to confirm until I can get the A.T. bucket list item checked off.

A quick google search suggests this is correct. Typically elevated off the ground and open on the front side. The screen and door seem to be an Isle Royale specific variant.

[treeplanter]

.....I think the reason that the shelters are only found at Lake Superior docks has more to do with the wilderness designation of most of the park. Since the Wilderness Act of 1964 states "there shall be no temporary road, no use of motor vehicles, motorized equipment or motorboats, no landing of aircraft, no other form of mechanical transport......

Isle Royale didn't become an official US designated wilderness until 1976. The shelters are located along Lake Superior campsites strictly because of ease of construction.

[MikeT]

You can see on the National Geographic map of the park, all the campgrounds with existing shelters have been carved out of the wilderness designation, which allows the park service to maintain and replace existing structures in those areas.

I like the theory, but I'm not sure it's 100% true. There are a lot of places that don't show on the map as non-wilderness that have shelters; Todd Harbor, Chippewa, Duncan Bay + Narrows, many of the small island campsites, etc.
I wouldn't doubt the reason, like pit toilets, is to minimize impact to the land, however.

The last Management Plan published has a whole section on removing both shelters and tables from the island to meet the wilderness designation.
From page 220 of Final Wilderness and Backcountry Management Plan published in 2011:
Alternative B for Picnic Tables: Comply with NPS Policy and Remove all Picnic Tables
from Wilderness Campgrounds
The details of this alternative are outlined in Chapter 2, p. 89-90. Changes that could occur
under this alternative that may have measurable environmental consequences include:
• All picnic tables would be removed from a total of 33 campsites and shelters in the
following campgrounds within designated or potential wilderness: Caribou Island,
Chippewa Harbor, Hay Bay, Grace Island, Beaver Island, Todd Harbor, Birch Island,
Duncan Bay, Duncan Narrows, Merritt Lane, and Tookers Island. The tables would also
be removed from the picnic area at Hidden Lake.
• Picnic tables would be retained at campgrounds in non-wilderness; Rock Harbor, Three
Mile, Daisy Farm, Moskey Basin, Malone Bay, Siskiwit Bay (only until the dock is
removed), Washington Creek, McCargoe Cove, and Belle Isle.
• Isle Royale would then be in compliance with NPS wilderness policy.
[There is another section just like this that talks about removing shelters at the same campgrounds)